"We are all in the gutter, but some of us..."
Taking Trash Seriously.
"...are looking at the stars."
-- Oscar Wilde
February 5, 2009
Price: Your 2¢

This site is updated Thursday afternoon with a new article about an artistic pursuit generally considered to be beneath consideration. James Schellenberg probes science-fiction, Carol Borden draws out the best in comics, Chris Szego dallies with romance and Ian Driscoll stares deeply into the screen. Click here for their bios and individual takes on the gutter. Our Guest Stars shine here

While the writers have considerable enthusiasm for their subjects, they don't let it numb their critical faculties. Tossing away the shield of journalistic objectivity and refusing the shovel of fannish boosterism, they write in the hopes of starting honest and intelligent discussions about these oft-enjoyed but rarely examined artforms. Contact us here.


Recent Features


A Straight Line from Neuromancer to Spook Country

spook_country-uk.jpgYour first book is a classic that essentially creates the modern era, or at least that's what people are saying. What do you do for an encore? In the case of William Gibson, you can just follow the same interests in a different form.

Continue reading...


It's Fun to Go to the R.W.A

bittyheart.JPGThe internet allows writers to do the impossible: write in isolation while in company. A writer might still face off single-handedly against blank screen, but behind the accusing blink of the cursor there are thousands of minds ready to offer information, support and catwaxing options.

On the other hand, it’s not as if, pre-internet, every writer was locked in a Proustian cork-lined room. Despite the solitary nature of their work - or possibly because of it - writers have always sought one another out. For encouragment, professional development, and sometimes for the sheer relief of being around other people who get it. That’s pretty much the unofficial definition of the RWA.

Continue reading...


HELLO DOCTOR NAME CONTINUE YESTERDAY TOMORROW

Top 80.jpgI had really hoped that my list of the top 10 films of the decade would be more surprising. Or perhaps I just assumed that I was less predictable. I thought about a lot of other films, some of which you’ll see in my runners-up rundown at the foot of this article, but these are the ones that stuck with me over the past ten years.

Continue reading...


Forgetful?

Perhaps you'd like an e-mail notification of our weekly update.

 
 

The Lonely Man

by Carol Borden

physician scientist 80.jpg

I used to be so impatient watching The Incredible Hulk. I curled up coloring, waiting for David Banner to transform and roar and smash through brick walls. But watching that show only for the Hulk sets any viewer up for disappointment. Instead, I've learned to watch The Incredible Hulk for David Banner. And, rewatching the show, I don't mind David Banner at all.

Running from 1978 to 1982, Marvel's live action series spanned the adult-oriented dramas and comedies of the 1970s, when anyone under 35 was a kid, to the less character- more explosion-driven shows of the 1980s. It starred Bill Bixby as Dr. David Banner, physician/scientist, Lou Ferrigno as the creature and Jack Colvin as Jack McGee, a tabloid reporter hunting the Hulk. Actually, the plot's well summarized in the show's still pretty swell opening.  I love the x-rays and platelets.

The Incredible Hulk was about a hero's ostensibly boring alter ego before Smallville or Lois and Clark, or before Tim Burton's Batman (1989) spent a lot of time on Bruce Wayne's psychology. In fact, by the time Kal-El was living full-time as Clark Kent in Superman II (1982), The Incredible Hulk had been canceled. As part of the focus on David Banner, the series also focused on mundane problems and human relationships. I think that's why some fans find the show kind of embarrassing. If you're used to looking for plot twists and waiting out conversations to get to the Hulk Smash, you're looking for the least gratifying part of this show. Worse yet, if you're only watching for problems caused by supervillains like The Leader, you will always be sad.

david banner 250.jpgWhile David Banner is provoked in many different ways, the show's tight discipline might rub structure monkeys wrong. Banner is a drifter, taking odd jobs and solving problems across the USA while searching for a cure or way to control “the creature.” David Banner “grows angry or outraged,” as the narrator says, and transforms twice each episode. His transformations help solve a problem, but afterwards, ashamed, he abandons whatever life—and research—he's only just begun. Then Joe Harnell's melancholy “The Lonely Man Theme” plays as David Banner hitchhikes from one life to another. David Banner will never have normal life.

The closing theme led me to consider the show's romance elements, something I never would've thought about before Chris started writing here. David Banner is a lonely man. Taken as a whole, the show follows David Banner as he grieves the death of his first wife in a car accident. The Hulk could even have arisen from his rage at his loss. Ladies fall for David Banner's compassion and sadness, but he turns them away, not just to protect them or because he's searching for a cure, though those are concerns. He definitely doesn't turn them away because he is a hero who, as Jules Feiffer writes, “could if he wanted to, but still didn't” (21). He turns them away because he's brokenhearted. Besides, David Banner only falls for science ladies and it never goes well. Mariette Hartley won an Emmy for her portrayal of David Banner's second wife, Dr. Caroline Fields, who dies of a terminal illness after his car breaks down while he's taking her to the hospital in a hurricane. Dr. Banner also transformed for the first time after hurting himself trying to change a tire in the rain. If this were the regular Marvel Universe, The Hulk would hate cars more than puny Banner.

But it isn't the regular Marvel Universe. Unlike Bruce Banner, the Hulk was not created when Banner was irradiated while saving someone during military testing. David Banner experimentally irradiates himself, trying to discover a way he could have saved his wife. And David Banner is not pursued by the military but by Jack McGee, a reporter for The National Register. In fact, David Banner never even calls the Hulk, “the Hulk.” He calls his metamorphosized self, “the creature.” Mr. McGee coins,“The Hulk,” as a slick, sellable name. The Hulk is also the show's only fantastic element. At least until The Incredible Hulk Returns (1988) and The Trial of the Incredible Hulk (1989) attempt to draw the series back into the Marvel Universe while catapulting Thor and Daredevil into their own series. But strangely, the movies seem more dated than the show, despite its bellbottoms and plaid jackets, even its disco and Blaxploitation episodes. The movies are much less adult. Then again, it's possible that “adult” as something other than a euphemism for sex, violence or swearing is a mark of a 1970s drama.

Now I like the focus on David Banner. I like how adult the show is, although I'd still play a game where the Hulk throws cars and smashes stuff. I enjoy pictures of creatures smashing. But having an interesting Banner, that's great.

~~~

Carol Borden is believed to be dead, and she must let the world think that she is dead, until she can find a way to control the raging spirit that dwells within her.

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

i like the way you express yourself. i especially like lines like "you will always be sad". the only line i do not like so much is the one at the top of the third-to-last paragraph that reads "The closing theme led made consider the show's..."

—estaban

thanks, estaban. I've fixed it.

—Carol Borden

*sniff* David Banner will never have a normal life . . .
Hi Carol,
I enjoyed this piece. One of the things I've been thinking about lately is how Bill Bixby plays David Banner as such a genuinely sweet man. He's so gentle in supposed contrast to his "creature," but even the Hulk in the show is such a big mush-pot. If someone compiled clips of him calming down and reverting to human form while petting bunnies, tiger cubs and fawns, I would watch that all the time.

HULK SMASH!
HULK PET KITTY!
Hulk feel surprisingly better.

—weed


Chuck your 2¢ into the Gutter
The Lonely Man - The Cultural Gutter
Lost your 2¢? Write us.

Paw through our archives

*sniff* David Banner will never have a normal life . . .
Hi Carol,
I enjoyed this piece. One of the things I've been thinking about lately is how Bill Bixby plays David Banner as such a genuinely sweet man. He's so gentle in supposed contrast to his "creature," but even the Hulk in the show is such a big mush-pot. If someone compiled clips of him calming down and reverting to human form while petting bunnies, tiger cubs and fawns, I would watch that all the time.

HULK SMASH!
HULK PET KITTY!
Hulk feel surprisingly better.

—weed

3 comments below.
Pitch in yours.


Of Note Elsewhere
Grant McCracken posits an "enmeshed male" theory of Burn Notice and a few of the other entertaining shows on the USA Network.
~
"A pretty harrowing movie, realistic in an emotional way that most war movies don't catch" - Joe Haldeman, on The Hurt Locker.
~
System Shock, a great videogame from 1994, gets a mod to make it easier to play for modern videogamers (with lots of tips in the comments on how to get the game running).
~
Marvel's animating my childhood with their upcoming Black Panther series for BET. (No, I wasn't T'Challa, the King of Wakanda. I just loved Black Panther). Animated Superheroes has the theme song as well as screen shots of characters and the voice-acting credits. (via Black SuperHero Blog).
~
Passive-Aggressive Man, a superhero powered by his self-hatred over his inability to confront assholes.
~

View all Notes here.
Seen something shiny? Gutter-talk worth hearing? Let us know!

On a Quest?

Pete Fairhurst made us this Mozilla search plug-in. Neat huh?

Obsessive?

Then you might be interested in knowing you can get an RSS Feed here, find us on Facebook there and that the site is autoconstructed by v4.01 of Movable Type and is hosted by No Media Kings.

Thanks To

Canada Council
We acknowledge the support of the Canada Council for the Arts which last year invested $20.3 million in writing and publishing throughout Canada.